Table 3:

Risk of bias for the included studies

StudyType of bias
Sequence generationAllocation concealmentBlinding of outcome assessmentIncomplete outcome dataSelective reportingOther
Chen et al.,28 2020LLLLLU
Losa-Reyna et al.,29 2019UUUHLL
Liu et al.,30 2018LUULLH
Clegg et al.,31 2014UUHULU
Liu et al.,32 2017HHULHH
Yoon et al.,33 2018UUUHLL
Takatori et al.,34 2016HHLHLL
Tarazona-Santabalbina et al.,35 2016UULLLU
Ng et al.,36,60,61 2015LLLLLL
Kwon et al.,37 2015LLLLLL
Tieland et al.,38 2015UUUHLU
Giné-Garriga et al.,39 2013LUHHLL
Daniel,40 2012UUULLH
Giné-Garriga et al.,41 2010LULHLL
Faber et al.,42 2006LULLLH
Binder et al.,43,5456 2005LULLLL
Gill et al.,44,59 2002LULULU
de Jong et al.,45,57,58 2000UUUULH
Brown et al.,46 2000UUULLU
Yarasheski et al.,47 1999UUUULU
Chandler et al.,48 1998LULLLL
Kuo et al.,49 2018LULLLU
Tsang et al.,50 2013UUULLH
Chen et al.,51 2010UUULLU
  • Note: H = high risk of bias, L = low risk of bias U = risk of bias unclear.