Study (year) | Location | Population | Period | Law(s) | Outcomes | Statistical methods |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sproule and Kennett (1988) (24) | Canada | All | 1972–1982 | Bill C-51 | Homicide | Analysis of variance |
Mundt (1990) (25) | Canada; United States | All | 1971–1988 | Bill C-51 | Homicide, suicide, accidental death | Visual inspection |
Rich et al. (1990) (26) | Toronto; San Diego | Males | 1973–1983 | Bill C-51 | Suicide | t tests, time series analysis |
Mauser and Holmes (1992) (27) | Canada (excluding Newfoundland and Labrador, and 3 territories) | All | 1968–1988 | Bill C-51 | Homicide | Pooled cross-section time series model |
Leenaars et al.* (1993,1994, 1996,1997, 2001, 2003) (18)– (23) | Canada | All | 1969–1985 | Bill C-51 | Homicide, suicide | t tests, simple linear regression, multiple regression, interrupted time series |
Carrington and Moyer (1994a) (28) | Ontario | All | 1965–1989 | Bill C-51 | Suicide | t tests, time series analysis |
Carrington and Moyer (1994b) (29) | Canada | All | 1965–1989 | Bill C-51 | Suicide | Interrupted time series |
Leenaars and Lester (1997) (30) | Canada | All | 1969–1985 | Bill C-51 | Accidental death | t tests, simple linear regression, multiple regression |
Bridges (2004) (31) | Canada | All | 1984–1998 | Bill C-17 | Homicide, suicide | t tests, simple linear regression |
Caron (2004) (32) | Abitibi-Témiscamingue, Que. | All | 1986–1996 | Bill C-17 | Suicide | χ2 and likelihood ratio tests |
Cheung and Dewa (2005) (33) | Canada | Age 15–19 years | 1979–1999 | Bill C-17 | Suicide | Time series models |
Caron et al. (2008) (34) | Quebec | All | 1987–2001 | Bill C-17 | Suicide | Linear regression, interrupted time series analysis, Pearson correlation coefficient analyses, multivariate analysis |
Gagne et al. (2010) (35) | Quebec | Males | 1981–2006 | Bill C-17 | Suicide | Joinpoint analysis, Poisson regression analysis |
Blais et al. (2011) (36) | Canada | All | 1974–2004 | Bill C-51, Bill C-17, Bill C-68 | Homicide | Multiple time series analysis |
Langmann (2012) (37) | Canada | All | 1974–2008 | Bill C-51, Bill C-17, Bill C-68 | Homicide | Interrupted time series Poisson regression, ARIMA, Joinpoint analysis |
Linteau and Blais (2013) (39) | Quebec | All | 1974–2006 | Bill C-68 | Homicide | Extreme bounds analysis |
McPhedran and Mauser (2013) (38) | Canada | All | 1974–2009 | Bill C-68 | Homicide, domestic homicide | ARIMA, Zivot–Andrews structural breakpoint test |
Langmann (2020) (40) | Canada | All | 1981–2016 | Bill C-17, Bill C-68 | Homicide, suicide | Difference in differences analysis, negative binomial regression |
Note: ARIMA = autoregressive integrated moving average.
↵* Data from multiple reports investigating the same legislation, population and outcome were collated.